Maybe there's a local Quaker and a local Catholic and they just turn into the Statler and Waldorf of the village! Crack uncharitable jokes, then turn to each other and high-five.

I don't think it's confirmed what happened to Tituba afterwards - we know Parris didn't bail her out of jail, and eventually he sold her to a mystery someone else who did, and that's all that we've got in the historical record, so the field is WIDE OPEN.