skygiants: Princess Tutu, facing darkness with a green light in the distance (land beyond dreams)
[personal profile] skygiants
So Patricia C. Wrede has her on days and her off days, and Snow White and Rose Red, which was my thesis-distraction book, is not really representative of her most on days.

The book is a perfectly serviceable retelling of the fairy tale in Elizabethan England, with bonus cameos from the ever-handy John Dee, but the characters never really reach any level of distinct personality and everyone's motivation is sort of murky at best. I think perhaps the problem is that Wrede sticks a little too close to the fairy-tale style of tell-not-show, which, while, again, a perfectly reasonable stylistic choice, doesn't really allow much character depth. Also I lost track of how often this basic exchange was repeated throughout the story:

Rosamund, aka Rose Red: Mother, let's do something dangerous!
Blanche, aka Snow White: I think we have a good reason to do this dangerous thing . . .
Mother: But it could be DANGEROUS!
Rosamund: But I am a spunky female character who gets annoyed when she isn't allowed to do dangerous things!
Blanche: And I am a slightly more thoughtful yet still active female character who would also like to be involved!
Rosamund: Anyways, what's the worst that could happen?
Blanche: True, we are unmarried young ladies going off into the woods, but we'll be careful. And it isn't like either of us is named Janet.
Mother: Fine, go off and do your dangerous thing. BUT DON'T GET BURNED AS WITCHES.

This is pretty much the extent of the characterization of these three. Except all in Elizabethan dialect - which was like the rest of the book, in that it was perfectly serviceable and not incorrect, but never felt quite natural. And I know Wrede can do natural-sounding historical chatter, because she pulls it off perfectly in Sorcery and Cecelia. (Obligatory shout-out: actually, the only author I can think of right now to pull off entirely natural-sounding Elizabethan is Kage Baker. Whom I love.) So, end verdict - I don't want to trash the book, because it's not terrible really, but it's definitely not the best example of Wrede's work. Also, it suffers in comparison to other retellings in the Fairy Tale series like Pamela Dean's Tam Lin and Jane Yolen's Briar Rose, both of which do something much more with their source stories than just retell them - but I should say that I may have been judging it more harshly than is fair, because I have kind of an addiction to fairy-tale reworkings, and what I am looking for in my favorites is not necessarily the same as what someone else might want.

Date: 2008-05-12 10:01 pm (UTC)
genarti: Knees-down view of woman on tiptoe next to bookshelves (reading by the seashore)
From: [personal profile] genarti
My memory of that book is pretty vague -- which is saying something itself -- but from what I do remember, my opinion is pretty much dead-on with yours.

It's not bad. It's kind of fun. You just finish it and go "...Okay. Was that all?"

Still not as bad as a couple of her early works, though. *wry* And I say this as someone who absolutely adores several of her books. But she is definitely a writer who has her on days and off days, as you say.

Profile

skygiants: Princess Tutu, facing darkness with a green light in the distance (Default)
skygiants

July 2025

S M T W T F S
  12345
678 9 1011 12
13141516171819
202122232425 26
2728293031  

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 29th, 2025 04:50 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios