(no subject)
Jul. 5th, 2024 10:42 amI'm continuing to trawl slowly through my reread of the Twelve Kingdoms books, one or two steps behind
jiggit -- in the last month I read Sea of Wind, Shores of the Labyrinth and A Thousand Leagues of Wind, the Sky at Dawn.
Reading Sea of Wind made me extremely glad that I'd decided to read Demon Child first, because even though the vibes are very different -- Demon Child is a psychological horror novel; Sea of Wind is a fantasy about finding your place and believing in yourself that culminates in an unambiguously happy ending unless you've already read some of the later books and know what's going to happen next! -- the themes dovetail in a way that I think makes both books richer and more complex.
In the first chapter of Sea of Wind, a baby kirin gets swept away by accident to our world. In the second or third chapter, he gets found and comes home again. So you feel you don't fit in the place you are: great! turns out you weren't from there and never belonged there! here's the magical land you came from, where you have a magical destiny, where everyone loves you, and where you're supposed to be. Wait, that doesn't fix you? Why doesn't it fix you? What if you'll never know everything you're supposed to know or be everything you're supposed to be?
Fuyumi Ono's portal fantasy is never a power fantasy; it's always about exploring feelings of alienation and inadequacy. Her worldbuilding is made up of literalized metaphors, unbreakable rules that can be nonsensical and often cruel, and her characters to make themselves strong enough to fill their roles or die. There's no escaping the world or changing its fundamental rules.
...but you can change it in other ways! A Thousand Leagues of Wind is also a little bit about alienation and inadequacy. But! it's also! about solidarity and direct action!!
The book begins with the new divinely appointed Empress of Kei taking her throne, to triumph and rejoicing! except for the fact that she's a portal fantasied modern Japanese teenager who has no idea how to govern, whether any of her ministers can be trusted to advise her, or what sort of change or policy prioritization would benefit the average citizen of her realm. Is it better to channel money towards infrastructure or farming? Is Minister X a righteous patriot who's angered his colleagues by his incorruptibility, or is he indeed secretly planning an assassination attempt? Who the hell knows, and certainly not [to her deep and depressed self-awareness] the Empress.
Meanwhile, news of the teen queen's coronation has reached two other teenagers: Suzu, another portal fantasied Japanese teenager who did not have the benefit of being a destined queen with a magical understanding of the language and who thus has been trapped in domestic service to an abusive noblewoman for 500 years; and Shoukei, the teen daughter of the failed king of another kingdom, whose privileged lifestyle was overturned when her beloved [but extremely tyrannical] parents were executed in front of her eyes.
Both Suzu and Shoukei are inspired by the news that a girl more or less like them -- a girl they can project onto to their heart's content -- has succeeded to the throne of Kei. Unfortunately, Suzu is inspired to travel around the country explaining to refugee children how much harder her life has been than theirs, and Shoukei is inspired to try and reclaim her privilege via poorly-planned criminal enterprise. Both of them are going to hit rock bottom before they start figuring out how to direct their anger at the world at a target that actually deserves it ... and meanwhile, the Empress of Kei herself, in trying to figure out how to be an ethical ruler, is getting closer and closer to starting a revolution against her own government! Let's Go, Teen Girl Squad!
I love terrible teen girls and I love revolution so what a book this is for me. The lectures about self-growth that Suzu and Shoukei receive On Their Journeys occasionally hit a little bit on the didactic side, but it's worth it as the plotlines start lining up and everything builds towards its big finish. I'm excited to hit the actual finale of the Twelve Kingdoms, but also frankly pretty braced for it not to in fact be anywhere near as satisfying for me as the ending of this book.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Reading Sea of Wind made me extremely glad that I'd decided to read Demon Child first, because even though the vibes are very different -- Demon Child is a psychological horror novel; Sea of Wind is a fantasy about finding your place and believing in yourself that culminates in an unambiguously happy ending unless you've already read some of the later books and know what's going to happen next! -- the themes dovetail in a way that I think makes both books richer and more complex.
In the first chapter of Sea of Wind, a baby kirin gets swept away by accident to our world. In the second or third chapter, he gets found and comes home again. So you feel you don't fit in the place you are: great! turns out you weren't from there and never belonged there! here's the magical land you came from, where you have a magical destiny, where everyone loves you, and where you're supposed to be. Wait, that doesn't fix you? Why doesn't it fix you? What if you'll never know everything you're supposed to know or be everything you're supposed to be?
Fuyumi Ono's portal fantasy is never a power fantasy; it's always about exploring feelings of alienation and inadequacy. Her worldbuilding is made up of literalized metaphors, unbreakable rules that can be nonsensical and often cruel, and her characters to make themselves strong enough to fill their roles or die. There's no escaping the world or changing its fundamental rules.
...but you can change it in other ways! A Thousand Leagues of Wind is also a little bit about alienation and inadequacy. But! it's also! about solidarity and direct action!!
The book begins with the new divinely appointed Empress of Kei taking her throne, to triumph and rejoicing! except for the fact that she's a portal fantasied modern Japanese teenager who has no idea how to govern, whether any of her ministers can be trusted to advise her, or what sort of change or policy prioritization would benefit the average citizen of her realm. Is it better to channel money towards infrastructure or farming? Is Minister X a righteous patriot who's angered his colleagues by his incorruptibility, or is he indeed secretly planning an assassination attempt? Who the hell knows, and certainly not [to her deep and depressed self-awareness] the Empress.
Meanwhile, news of the teen queen's coronation has reached two other teenagers: Suzu, another portal fantasied Japanese teenager who did not have the benefit of being a destined queen with a magical understanding of the language and who thus has been trapped in domestic service to an abusive noblewoman for 500 years; and Shoukei, the teen daughter of the failed king of another kingdom, whose privileged lifestyle was overturned when her beloved [but extremely tyrannical] parents were executed in front of her eyes.
Both Suzu and Shoukei are inspired by the news that a girl more or less like them -- a girl they can project onto to their heart's content -- has succeeded to the throne of Kei. Unfortunately, Suzu is inspired to travel around the country explaining to refugee children how much harder her life has been than theirs, and Shoukei is inspired to try and reclaim her privilege via poorly-planned criminal enterprise. Both of them are going to hit rock bottom before they start figuring out how to direct their anger at the world at a target that actually deserves it ... and meanwhile, the Empress of Kei herself, in trying to figure out how to be an ethical ruler, is getting closer and closer to starting a revolution against her own government! Let's Go, Teen Girl Squad!
I love terrible teen girls and I love revolution so what a book this is for me. The lectures about self-growth that Suzu and Shoukei receive On Their Journeys occasionally hit a little bit on the didactic side, but it's worth it as the plotlines start lining up and everything builds towards its big finish. I'm excited to hit the actual finale of the Twelve Kingdoms, but also frankly pretty braced for it not to in fact be anywhere near as satisfying for me as the ending of this book.