skygiants: Hikaru from Ouran walking straight into Tamaki's hand (talk to the hand)
[personal profile] skygiants
At first I expected to write a rather scathing post about Rachel Kadish's The Weight of Ink, and then I got like 2/3 of the way through and realized that there were in fact some things I really liked about the book to counteract the things that made me stare into the camera like I was on the office, and THEN I got to the end and -

-- ok let me backtrack. The Weight of Ink is a serious literary novel about a pair of academics (the favorite protagonists of serious literary novels) who have discovered a treasure trove of 17th-century documents in a staircase written by Ester Velasquez, a Portuguese Jewish woman who Confounded All Tradition by acting as scribe for a London rabbi. The book proceeds to interweave Ester's story and POV with that of the academics as they discover various bits of evidence pointing to the things that Rachel Kadish will then later explain to us in Ester's narrative sections.

Ester's story is .... it's mostly good? I think I have come around to largely thinking it's good. It starts to pick up around the middle of the book, when Ester starts writing letters to various famous philosophers under fake male names so that she can Engage in the Discourse.

[ACADEMIC A: [Ester's fake name] did not get much attention during his career or make any important allies -
ACADEMIC B: Oh, why is that?
ACADEMIC A: Well, basically, he was very rude to everyone he wrote to.

I will admit I was charmed.]

Ester's most important relationships are with the rabbi -- a good and wise man who respects her intellect and cannot support the ways in which she chooses to use it -- and with Rivka, the rabbi's housekeeper, a Polish Jew who acts as Ester's foil in a number of significant ways, not all of them obvious or expected. Both of these dynamics have an interesting and complicated tension to them that goes well beyond the standard 'I, A Misunderstood Woman Ahead Of My Time.'

Also there is another young upper-class Jewish woman who is rebellious in wildly different ways than Ester is; a pair of brothers who are both interested in marrying Ester for profoundly different reasons, neither of which is true love; and, for a brief period of time, a love interest. The love interest is hilariously lacking in personality and equally hilariously irrelevant to Ester's life on the whole, and mostly exists to trigger a series of philosophical musings related to desire about which Ester can fight with Spinoza. I guess The Distant Shadow Of Spinoza is also one of Ester's most significant relationships.

Anyway, I appreciate the weighting of these relationships, and the way in which the narrative emphasis shifted from what I expected, and especially all the relationships that were not grounded in romance, but in other forms of love and duty and resentment and complicated emotional bonds.

And ... then there's our modern academics.

Helen Watt is a stiff-necked elderly British specialist in Jewish history, who is on the verge of retirement due to Parkinson's disease. Helen has a Tragic Backstory: in her youth, she spent a month as a volunteer in Israel in the 1950s and had a summer fling. Sorry, let me rephrase: she met an Israeli soldier who was the love! of her life!! (For a month.)

The pivotal scene in their romance occurs when Helen shows up for one of their few actual shared off days to have a date, and he hands her a copy of The History of the Jewish People and then LEAVES and REFUSES TO COME BACK until she's READ IT COVER TO COVER. This is the only way she can understand our endless, endless oppression!

(Meanwhile, he lurks outside, and periodically brings her snacks. THIS SCENE IS SOMEHOW NOT MEANT TO BE COMIC.)

Alas, Young Helen in her frailty decides it's all a LITTLE too much for her, and subsequently regrets her lost love until the end of her days. But, inspired by the world's weirdest date, she decides to dedicate her life to the study of Jewish history, so I guess ... that's all right .....?

She is assisted in her endeavors by Aaron, the third POV character. Aaron is an insufferable American Jewish Ph.D. student. He is working on a dissertation about Shakespeare and the Jews, for which he has no evidence, so instead he spends the entire book obsessing over an unattainable Cool Girl. (And she is so textbook Cool Girl! The coolest girl of all! A girl who poses nude for artists who capture a certain something about her, a girl who's just realer than other girls, THE MAGICAL IDEAL.) He sends her incredibly long, pompous emails after a one-night stand which took place on an evening in which "he waited until Marisa was on her second beer -- he kept track from a distance, biding his time. When he approached at last, his own untouched beer dangling casually in his hand --" OKAY AARON, THANKS AND GOODBYE, YOU AND I ARE DONE.

But alas, we are not done with Aaron, we are not done with Aaron at all. Eventually Aaron does come to realize that he's insufferable! A significant part of this realization comes when he visits an archive and meets a shy, demure archivist who's bad at flirting, and is suddenly struck by how desperately sad it is that people like her may never find love because they're all overlooked by assholes like him. If only people like him paid attention to people like her, their lives might be fulfilling and the world would be better! ALAS.

(There are two other archivists in the book, The Interchangeable Patricias. They have a few moments of heroically rising to Helen's aid but mostly their role is to stand as icily competent, largely humorless glowering gate-guards over the sacred text, because of course.)

So basically everything about the modern sections was nonsense to me. (Also, I got mad every time they found a document that explained to them a Piece of the Mystery in a way that was way too narratively convenient. 'Oh, look, Ester doodled out her real name and her fake name next to each other and added a note that said 'HEY IT'S ALL MY NAMES!' Isn't that handy!')

Still, Ester's story in and of itself was good and compelling and interesting, and grudgingly I became invested in it despite myself...


So part of Ester's tragic backstory is that her mother was the daughter of an illegitimate fling between her own mother (Ester's grandmother) and an unnamed, married Englishman.

In a total non sequitur, it turns out the married Englishman ....






Date: 2017-09-15 03:59 am (UTC)
sovay: (PJ Harvey: crow)
From: [personal profile] sovay

Up until the reveal, I was thinking what a tragedy it is when quite good historical novels get awkwardly sandwiched into modern literary frames.

After the reveal, I was thinking what a tragedy it is when historical crack does not go for broke and just put Shakespeare onstage.

Date: 2017-09-15 04:48 pm (UTC)
sovay: (PJ Harvey: crow)
From: [personal profile] sovay
Young Jewish Philosophical Genius Haunted By The Ghost Of Her Granddad, William Shakespeare: a different but WAY BETTER book.

Don't forget the Distant Shadow of Spinoza!

Date: 2017-09-16 02:50 am (UTC)
sovay: (Sydney Carton)
From: [personal profile] sovay
And featuring Spinoza as

I'd read it.

Date: 2017-09-16 07:40 pm (UTC)
From: [personal profile] plinythemammaler

do you know about the spinoza opera

Date: 2017-09-16 07:45 pm (UTC)
From: [personal profile] plinythemammaler
The Rise of Spinoza opens with dark, mysterious rumblings from the orchestra in a darkened hall. The lights go on slowly to fervent cries from market vendors: “butterrrrr, cheese, eggs!” in loud, polyrhythmic, yet minutely notated cacophony.

In the second scene François van den Ende exhorts Spinoza to become a catholic, yet the young philosopher indignantly refuses because of the murderous doings of the Inquisition. Van Eyck breaks the tension with a folk-like melody that is taken up by the orchestra, the jaunty music forming a welcome counterpoint to the serious issues at hand.

Historical crack

Date: 2017-09-15 06:08 pm (UTC)
kathmandu: Close-up of pussywillow catkins. (Default)
From: [personal profile] kathmandu
So Hikaru no Go -> Ester no Literature? Ghostly guidance and dramatically intense competition?

Date: 2017-09-16 02:25 am (UTC)
sophia_sol: drawing of Combeferre, smiling and holding up a finger like he's about to explain something (Default)
From: [personal profile] sophia_sol
I would read this version of the book!

Date: 2017-09-15 07:14 am (UTC)
allchildren: kay eiffel's face meets the typewriter (Default)
From: [personal profile] allchildren

Date: 2017-09-15 09:27 am (UTC)
vass: Jon Stewart reading a dictionary (books)
From: [personal profile] vass
a pair of academics (the favorite protagonists of serious literary novels)

*appreciative snort*

But, inspired by the world's weirdest date, she decides to dedicate her life to the study of Jewish history, so I guess ... that's all right .....?

I guess these things happen.

The Interchangeable Patricias

Maybe they're the protagonist from Jo Walton's My Real Children. (A Patricia who diverged into two different timelines (Pat and Trish for convenience) depending on whether she married the guy who proposed to her or not.)



Date: 2017-09-15 01:14 pm (UTC)
seekingferret: Word balloon says "So I said to the guy: you never read the book yet you go online and talk about it as if--" (Default)
From: [personal profile] seekingferret

I'm sorry, because I'm laughing so hard right now. That's almost terrible enough to be one of my ideas for a date.

Date: 2017-09-15 03:40 pm (UTC)
larryhammer: pen-and-ink drawing of an annoyed woman dressed as a Heian-era male courtier saying "......" (argh)
From: [personal profile] larryhammer


Date: 2017-09-15 04:14 pm (UTC)
davidgillon: A pair of crutches, hanging from coat hooks, reflected in a mirror (Default)
From: [personal profile] davidgillon
I suppose if you're going to have the insufferable Aaron as a point of view character, then it might seem to make sense to have the plot justify it in some way.

Emphasis on 'seem' {rolls eyes}

Date: 2017-09-16 01:12 am (UTC)
genarti: Thor, eyes half-closed, looking as if he's taking a moment to process something headache-inducing ([mcu] ugh you did not)
From: [personal profile] genarti
This sounds like a really good historical novel with an annoying frame story... that then has a pointless celebrity twist made extra annoying because UGH AARON SHOULDN'T GET TO FEEL SMUG ABOUT ANYTHING. Dare I hope that Aaron ~tragically~ never learns this factoid about Ester? (I am resignedly figuring that Aaron gets to learn this factoid about Ester.)

Date: 2017-09-17 06:20 pm (UTC)
genarti: Me covering my face with one hand. ([me] face. palm.)
From: [personal profile] genarti
The sad thing is, it sounds like that's genuine character growth for Aaron...

Date: 2017-09-16 01:47 am (UTC)
marginaliana: Buddy the dog carries Bobo the toy (Default)
From: [personal profile] marginaliana
I... what.

You've got to love hate love a dramatic non sequitur ancestry reveal, and you've got to love surprise!Shakespeare, but somehow together it's just... no. Wow.

Date: 2017-09-16 03:57 am (UTC)
bookblather: A picture of Yomiko Readman looking at books with the text "bookgasm." (Default)
From: [personal profile] bookblather

This is like that one book I read once where a secret Catholic cultist decided to become Pope via pretending to be Jewish for forty years.

Date: 2017-09-16 07:46 pm (UTC)
From: [personal profile] plinythemammaler
From like, the dustjacket this is exactly a book I WOULD have read so thank you so much for saving me from the terrible PoV Aaron, oh my *god*

Date: 2017-09-17 12:04 am (UTC)
From: [personal profile] hippogriff13
On a slightly related note, I have now read the first two installments in Marie Brennan's "Lady Trent, AU-Victorian lady explorer and dragon naturalist" series ("A Natural History of Dragons" and "Tropic of Serpents"), and I think Segulism, the dominant religion of Not!England (Scirland) and Not!Europe (Anthiope) in general, is supposed to be some sort of alternate universe version of Judaism, complete with some kind of past Protestant Reformation-type schism between the Church/Temple of Scirland-type branch and the Eastern Orthodox-type branch adhered to by the quasi-Russian/Eastern European villagers in the country the future Lady Trent and her husband and patron go to on their initial dragon-studying expedition. I have no idea how historically plausible it is that Judaism might have evolved this way in a world where it, instead of Christianity, presumably became the official religion of the local equivalent of the Roman Empire over a thousand years earlier. But the characters do refer to the Segulist houses of worship as temples (with old-fashioned sex-segregated seating in the Not!Eastern Orthodox versions), and some of the infrequently-mentioned religious terminology looks a lot like Hebrew (at least to a person who doesn't actually speak Hebrew).

Date: 2017-09-17 01:03 pm (UTC)
obopolsk: (Default)
From: [personal profile] obopolsk
So part of Ester's tragic backstory is that her mother was the daughter of an illegitimate fling between her own mother (Ester's grandmother) and an unnamed, married Englishman.

In a total non sequitur, it turns out the married Englishman ....



How did no one, at any point in the publication process, point out that maybe this doesn't quite work.

Also, this book sounds in some ways like a novel I tried to write in college, and very thankfully abandoned.


skygiants: Princess Tutu, facing darkness with a green light in the distance (Default)

October 2017

12 34 567
8 910111213 14
151617 18192021

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Oct. 19th, 2017 05:54 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios