(no subject)

[skygiants]

osprey_archer mentioned Paperback Crush: The Totally Radical History of 80s and 90s Fiction a few weeks back, so I picked it up on the assumption that it would be a good light nonfiction read for a recent beach trip.

And indeed it was, and I enjoyed the survey view of the era and the nostalgia hit of flipping through endless Sweet Valley High and Babysitters Club covers very much, while also very deeply craving a much more substantive and academic exploration of late-twentieth-century children's fiction -- sure, Sweet Valley High kicked off a landslide of Soap Opera Twin Story imitators, I'm glad to know this, but why was it so popular? Why and how did it cover the plotlines that it did? LET'S DIG, LET'S GET IN IT.

This book covers a lot of the broad trends, but doesn't really get in it at more than surface level. It also completely skips the categories that were most significant to me, fantasy and historical fiction, except where they overlap with the ones she's more interested in, Teen Romance and Teen Horror -- I realize the Harry Potter boom didn't happen until the early two thousands, but there were kid fantasy novels being published before then, and I read ALL of them. The boundary line in this book between what counts as 'teen' and 'kid' lit is is kind of fuzzy too and I think the definitions really depend on what Gabrielle Moss felt like writing about at the time. (For example, no American Girls, but a loving full-page spread on Wait Til Helen Comes which -- great book! Well worth calling out! NOT teen fiction, definitely a children's book.)

All that said, I learned several extremely important things from this book:

- there existed a Preteen Friends series (a la Babysitter's Club) called the B.Y. Times about a group of Orthodox Jewish girls who wrote for their school newspaper -- how did I not know about this! why have I not read all of them!
- there also existed a whole series called Swept Away, by Eileen Goudge, about teen girls who have a TIME TRAVEL CLUB (with a machine they stole from their local library! makerspaces, man) and are constantly zooming backwards to fix the love lives of Teen Girls From The Past; why did I not ALSO read all of these?
- noted horror author R.L. Stine also wrote joke books! ... under the name JOVIAL BOB Stine. I don't know why this is the funniest thing I've heard all week but every time I remember it I start laughing. Jovial Bob!
- Lois Duncan, who wrote all those teen horror and suspense books about teens and mysteries and murder ... stopped writing suspense novels after her ACTUAL teen daughter was mysteriously murdered, and instead wrote a true crime novel titled Who Killed My Daughter? based on her private investigation involving gangs and psychics! This is very sad, but also, good lord, talk about art imitating life
- on a lighter note, one last 'why didn't I read this': Samantha Slade, Monster-Sitter, "for the Goosebumps reader who wanted more babysitting, or the BSC reader who wanted more lycanthropy." I WAS BOTH THOSE THINGS. WHERE WAS I.

Anyway, now I have to go nosedive into all the Sweet Valley summaries written by dedicated scholar 1bruce1, still apparently valiantly trucking away on Livejournal after all this time.

Comments

[sovay]

I read the Babysitters Club, and some Sweet Valley High when my parents tried to encourage me to read more non-fantasy fiction; I'd trot home with my token Wakefield book on a pile of ten fantasy novels and call it good enough.

As far as I can tell, I read exactly one Baby-Sitters Club: Claudia and the Bad Joke (1988). It's the one where Claudia breaks her leg thanks to a practical joke with a sabotaged swingset, after which I have the creeping recollection that the rest of the club teaches the kid who plays mean-spirited practical jokes that practical jokes are bad by playing a mean-spirited one on her, which I guess is a moral? I have no idea why I read it. Other kids in my class may have been reading the series. I have a peculiarly vivid memory of the cover and the scene where the actual injury happens and then the rest of it is a plot-shaped blank.

I'm pretty sure the only thing I remember about Sweet Valley High is a TV commercial for a (tabletop?) game based on the series. It had a very '80's jingle: "You can be a Sweet Valley Girl / Going with a Sweet Valley Guy / Living in a Sweet Valley World / Getting into Sweet Valley High!" That's taken up space in my brain for thirty years.

[edit] AAAAAAH I FOUND IT. "High school is so cool!" Wow, I'm glad that did not forecast my actual experience of secondary education.

[skygiants]

I read many Baby-Sitters Club books but the only one I really remember is the one where Kristy's little sister befriends a cat that she thinks MIGHT be a ghost cat, but turns out to be just a deaf cat, which is why it doesn't respond to normal cat stimuli. For years I thought all blue-eyed cats were deaf because of this.

LIVING IN A SWEET VALLEY WORLD WOULD BE AN ABSOLUTE NIGHTMARE. I've read enough recaps to be aware of all the many, many drawbacks!

[sovay]

the one where Kristy's little sister befriends a cat that she thinks MIGHT be a ghost cat, but turns out to be just a deaf cat, which is why it doesn't respond to normal cat stimuli.

I feel that is a missed opportunity to introduce a ghost cat into your otherwise realist series.

For years I thought all blue-eyed cats were deaf because of this.

Well, a lot of them are.

I've read enough recaps to be aware of all the many, many drawbacks!

Everyone has evil twins?

[skygiants]

Sometimes even the evil twins have evil twins!