(no subject)
Apr. 19th, 2026 08:26 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
skygiantsI've been meaning for months to write up Knight Flower, the Joseon-era kdrama about a RESPECTABLE WIDOW BY DAY, VIGILANTE BY NIGHT who spends her days dutifully kneeling by her husband's portrait and serving her mother-in-law and her nights running around town in a black mask dispensing justice by the sword.
I enjoyed this drama very much, but it's kind of an odd beast -- it's genuinely interested in the awful constraints on Joseon's women's worlds and widow's worlds in particular and wants to explore that seriously, and it also wants have our heroine be extremely cool and fight off five guys in an alley every episode and toss off a one-liner about it, and it also wants our [middle-aged! widow!] heroine to be a charming sitcom naif who gets comically overcome by the sight of a man's midriff and is shocked! shocked! to learn about some of the various injustices going on in Joseon despite the fact that she's been wandering the streets dispensing vigilante justice for ten years. (They attempt to square some of this circle by virtue of the fact that our heroine's arranged husband was killed! by bandits! on his very wedding day! and so she has spent ten years dutifully mourning a man she never actually met, let alone slept with.)
And because Lee Hanee is a talented actress, she can almost more or less pull all of that off and make RESPECTABLE WIDOW SECRET VIGILANTE JO YEO-HWA a coherent character -- helped in large part by the various interesting women around her, including:
- Yeo-hwa's hard-nosed and cynical maid, whom Yeo-hwa rescued off the streets as a teenager, and who has spent her years since then in the single-minded pursuit of enough money for An Independent Place, which she is going to move into JUST as soon as her chaotic mistress to whom she is unfortunately absolutely loyal is Out Of This Fucking House and No Longer Doing This Stupid Vigilante Shit
- Yeo-hwa's mother-in-law, who holds Yeo-hwa harshly to the extremely narrow line of conduct allowed for widows [go nowhere; speak to no one; serve your husband's family; accept that it's an embarrassment for you to be alive when your husband is dead] and sees her largely as a walking reputational vector for the family -- but hey, at least she would never pressure Yeo-hwa to commit honorable suicide, like some other mother-in-laws-of-widows of their acquaintance, so that's something! In any other drama this character would be a cruel stereotype but in this drama she's played by Kim Mi-kyung with sympathy and complexity; she's the immediate bane of Yeo-hwa's life, and nonetheless she and Yeo-hwa have spent a decade bound together as family with a kind of affection, and Yeo-hwa understands perfectly well that her mother-in-law is also trapped by the only rules she knows
- Yeo-hwa's business partner and accomplice, a merchant whom Yeo-hwa also rescued on the streets and who has also spent the time since then like You Could Just Leave This Fucking House, I will prepare a fake identity for you, it won't be hard
- the main female villain, a sympathetic abused wife, known as a paragon of virtue around the town, who takes an interest in Yeo-hwa and encourages her mother-in-law to let her participate in approved paragon-of-virtue social activities -- who also then poisons her husband (no jury would convict etc) and is also eventually revealed to have been part of the long-term plot to kill the king many years ago (some juries would convict), and navigates between the roles of conspirator and societal victim in a way that consistently left us guessing which way she was going to turn
Obviously Jo Yeo-hwa also has a love interest. He's an honorable baby cop who wants to fight corruption and also has a backstory tied up in the ten-years-ago political plot. He's completely fine. His older brother, an upright schemer who's been helping the virtuous king lay long-term plots to take back control from his evil ministers,* has an very cute B-plot bookstore romance with the cynical maid that I frankly found much more compelling in the glimpses of it that we got. More compelling yet is the late-show reveal that YEO-HWA'S HUSBAND ISN'T DEAD. His evil father faked his son's death and arranged Yeo-hwa's marriage in order to have leverage over her brother and keep her safely be-widowed in his house, knowing full well that his son had scandalously already ELOPED to CHINA with his TRUE LOVE ...
... and now he's back! What was he doing all this time? What happened to the Chinese true love? Why is he constantly sprinkling his sentences with pop English like he's been isekai'd into this whole situation? We'll never know but it's EXTREMELY funny to watch this amiable prodigal son put together, in order, that a.) the rest of his family has believed he's dead for a decade b.) he's got a wife and c.) said wife is secretly a vigilante who's sneaking out of the house every night to Fight for Justice, and go "huh! well, I guess we'll see how this plays out" and amiably do his best to cover for her while she panics and punches him in the face. Frankly I would happily have watched a whole drama where this was the main romance premise, instead of getting it crammed into the back three episodes of the show, but it's fine. If Yeo-hwa wants her nice baby cop she can have her nice baby cop.
However it does set up my actual biggest disappointment of the show, which is that the whole drama feels like it's setting up for a major Worm Turns moment when Yeo-hwa's mother-in-law -- who truly believes with her whole heart that her husband is the pinnacle of honorable Confucian values, and that as a result it's her job and Yeo-hwa's job and everybody else's job to act just as properly -- finds out about the schemes and the lying and the deliberate faking of her beloved son's death and triumphantly rejects him, and ... then the show just does not make time for it, which is a shame because it feels thematically crucial. But in some ways that's my main issue with the show, I think! It's a very good time but every time it starts to get close to narrowing on its themes, it immediately distracts itself with hijinks music.
*there's nothing kdramas love more than a virtuous king who's trying to take back control from his evil ministers
I enjoyed this drama very much, but it's kind of an odd beast -- it's genuinely interested in the awful constraints on Joseon's women's worlds and widow's worlds in particular and wants to explore that seriously, and it also wants have our heroine be extremely cool and fight off five guys in an alley every episode and toss off a one-liner about it, and it also wants our [middle-aged! widow!] heroine to be a charming sitcom naif who gets comically overcome by the sight of a man's midriff and is shocked! shocked! to learn about some of the various injustices going on in Joseon despite the fact that she's been wandering the streets dispensing vigilante justice for ten years. (They attempt to square some of this circle by virtue of the fact that our heroine's arranged husband was killed! by bandits! on his very wedding day! and so she has spent ten years dutifully mourning a man she never actually met, let alone slept with.)
And because Lee Hanee is a talented actress, she can almost more or less pull all of that off and make RESPECTABLE WIDOW SECRET VIGILANTE JO YEO-HWA a coherent character -- helped in large part by the various interesting women around her, including:
- Yeo-hwa's hard-nosed and cynical maid, whom Yeo-hwa rescued off the streets as a teenager, and who has spent her years since then in the single-minded pursuit of enough money for An Independent Place, which she is going to move into JUST as soon as her chaotic mistress to whom she is unfortunately absolutely loyal is Out Of This Fucking House and No Longer Doing This Stupid Vigilante Shit
- Yeo-hwa's mother-in-law, who holds Yeo-hwa harshly to the extremely narrow line of conduct allowed for widows [go nowhere; speak to no one; serve your husband's family; accept that it's an embarrassment for you to be alive when your husband is dead] and sees her largely as a walking reputational vector for the family -- but hey, at least she would never pressure Yeo-hwa to commit honorable suicide, like some other mother-in-laws-of-widows of their acquaintance, so that's something! In any other drama this character would be a cruel stereotype but in this drama she's played by Kim Mi-kyung with sympathy and complexity; she's the immediate bane of Yeo-hwa's life, and nonetheless she and Yeo-hwa have spent a decade bound together as family with a kind of affection, and Yeo-hwa understands perfectly well that her mother-in-law is also trapped by the only rules she knows
- Yeo-hwa's business partner and accomplice, a merchant whom Yeo-hwa also rescued on the streets and who has also spent the time since then like You Could Just Leave This Fucking House, I will prepare a fake identity for you, it won't be hard
- the main female villain, a sympathetic abused wife, known as a paragon of virtue around the town, who takes an interest in Yeo-hwa and encourages her mother-in-law to let her participate in approved paragon-of-virtue social activities -- who also then poisons her husband (no jury would convict etc) and is also eventually revealed to have been part of the long-term plot to kill the king many years ago (some juries would convict), and navigates between the roles of conspirator and societal victim in a way that consistently left us guessing which way she was going to turn
Obviously Jo Yeo-hwa also has a love interest. He's an honorable baby cop who wants to fight corruption and also has a backstory tied up in the ten-years-ago political plot. He's completely fine. His older brother, an upright schemer who's been helping the virtuous king lay long-term plots to take back control from his evil ministers,* has an very cute B-plot bookstore romance with the cynical maid that I frankly found much more compelling in the glimpses of it that we got. More compelling yet is the late-show reveal that YEO-HWA'S HUSBAND ISN'T DEAD. His evil father faked his son's death and arranged Yeo-hwa's marriage in order to have leverage over her brother and keep her safely be-widowed in his house, knowing full well that his son had scandalously already ELOPED to CHINA with his TRUE LOVE ...
... and now he's back! What was he doing all this time? What happened to the Chinese true love? Why is he constantly sprinkling his sentences with pop English like he's been isekai'd into this whole situation? We'll never know but it's EXTREMELY funny to watch this amiable prodigal son put together, in order, that a.) the rest of his family has believed he's dead for a decade b.) he's got a wife and c.) said wife is secretly a vigilante who's sneaking out of the house every night to Fight for Justice, and go "huh! well, I guess we'll see how this plays out" and amiably do his best to cover for her while she panics and punches him in the face. Frankly I would happily have watched a whole drama where this was the main romance premise, instead of getting it crammed into the back three episodes of the show, but it's fine. If Yeo-hwa wants her nice baby cop she can have her nice baby cop.
However it does set up my actual biggest disappointment of the show, which is that the whole drama feels like it's setting up for a major Worm Turns moment when Yeo-hwa's mother-in-law -- who truly believes with her whole heart that her husband is the pinnacle of honorable Confucian values, and that as a result it's her job and Yeo-hwa's job and everybody else's job to act just as properly -- finds out about the schemes and the lying and the deliberate faking of her beloved son's death and triumphantly rejects him, and ... then the show just does not make time for it, which is a shame because it feels thematically crucial. But in some ways that's my main issue with the show, I think! It's a very good time but every time it starts to get close to narrowing on its themes, it immediately distracts itself with hijinks music.
*there's nothing kdramas love more than a virtuous king who's trying to take back control from his evil ministers
no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 08:54 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 09:30 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 09:51 pm (UTC)One of the things I found interesting was how the character arc (towards freedom) was at odds with the romance arc (towards relationship), and how they couldn't really reconcile them within the given runtime, so they just kind of side-stepped the problem. It seems ripe for fanfic fixits/elaborations (which makes sense, given I found the show via the Yuletide tagset). :-)
tl;dr Lee Hanee is super delightful.
no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 09:59 pm (UTC)10/10, would watch entire show if it existed. Also the bookstore romance. I am sorry this show kept running out of time for itself.
no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 10:22 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 10:26 pm (UTC)(And I should definitely check out the Yuletide tagset!)
no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 10:27 pm (UTC)Yay.
Which reminds me to ask you to remind me the name of that movie about the fake husband in the POW camp I've been meaning to watch for many years.
The Captive Heart (1946)! See also Libel (1959).
no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 10:31 pm (UTC)Yeah, I really wanted at least one more episode to give more time for the denouement to play out. Even aside from the dangling plot threads, there was a threat that the whole family would be executed for the dad's crimes and I would have loved some time to sit with that and have it feel real and have everyone make choices about it.
no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 10:35 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-19 10:35 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-20 04:31 am (UTC):)) I love most of the variants of this topos that I've met, but it is always rather ... but ... really?
The show sounds great despite (or with?) its shying away from key moments! Thanks for writing it up.
no subject
Date: 2026-04-20 04:36 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-20 04:42 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-20 07:30 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-21 01:07 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-23 12:11 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-23 12:12 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 11:24 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 11:30 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 11:30 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 11:33 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 11:34 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 11:35 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 11:36 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 03:30 pm (UTC)In fairness, the power of some rl individuals to disregard inconvenient niceties so that they can keep being themselves is, uh, a thing that I for one keep underestimating. (People I've met, not random celebs or corporate heads.)
no subject
Date: 2026-04-24 03:34 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-25 12:53 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-25 01:05 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-25 01:17 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2026-04-25 02:04 pm (UTC)